Sal Stewart (Photo: Redleg Nation Staff)
Sal Stewart (Photo: Redleg Nation Staff)

Reds infielder Sal Stewart named Rookie of the Year finalist

The 2026 National League Rookie of the Year award will be announced on Monday, November 9th. But we know who the announcement will come down to as it was announced that Cincinnati Reds infielder Sal Stewart, St. Louis Cardinals infielder JJ Wetherholt, and New York Mets outfielder Carson Benge were the finalists for the award. You can watch the announcement at 7:00pm ET on MLB Network.

After a strong debut in the final month of the 2025 season where he hit .255/.293/.545, Sal Stewart earned a spot on the opening day roster in 2026. He got out to a hot start, hitting .281/.373/.570 through April while hitting nine home runs and driving in 29 runs. He also stole seven bases in seven tries.

Things slowed down a little bit over the next two months as he hit under .250 in both months and had seven home runs to go along with 30 runs batted in. Stewart picked things back up in July, though, and was named a National League All-Star. In the 54 games he played in July and August he hit .280/.329/.521 with 15 home runs and he added in another 46 runs batted in.

When the month of August came to an end he was leading the National League in RBI. But things did not go well in the final month of the year for Stewart at the plate. He hit just .247/.287/.280 in the final 24 games with just one extra-base hit and just six runs batted in. The slow down would cost him the RBI title as he finished with 112 on the season, finishing in 2nd place in the league (Alec Burleson – 116 RBI).

Sal Stewart played in all 162 games for the Reds during the season. Only once did he not start a game – July 26th in St. Louis when he came off the bench to pinch hit in the 10th inning and had an RBI single. He would get 700 plate appearances and hit .263/.330/.457. That came along with 25 doubles, 32 home runs, 112 RBI, 15 stolen bases, and 87 runs scored.

Stewart led all National League rookies with his 112 RBI. TJ Rumfield was a very distant second with 73. He also led NL rookies with 32 home runs. Carson Benge was a distant second with his 20. The 25 doubles for the Reds infielder were second to Rumfield’s 30 and his 87 runs scored trailed just JJ Wetherholt’s 89.

When it comes to the three finalists, Stewart was a clear third when it comes to defense. Wetherholt stood out as a second baseman who saw some time at shortstop. Benge spent most of his time in right field, but saw limited action in both left and center during the season. He led the league with 10 assists and two double plays from the outfield.

It will be interesting to see how the voters weighed offense – and more specifically traditional, old-school numbers like home runs and RBI – against defense. Stewart had enormous, comical leads in both RBI and home runs over the rest of the field. But he gave back some value due to his defense and his defensive position. No matter which version of WAR you choose to look at, Stewart is a distant third place among the finalists. His offensive contributions were pulled down by his baserunning and defensive value, while the other two saw their defensive value and baserunning boost their overall production.