Sal Stewart put up some big numbers at the plate in 2026. The Cincinnati Reds rookie hit 32 home runs, which were third most in baseball among rookies and led the National League. Stewart also drove in 112 runs, which led all of Major League Baseball among rookies. He hit for a .263 batting average, which was 16th among rookies with at least 250 plate appearances. His .330 on-base percentage was 18th among that same group of rookies. And his .457 slugging percentage ranked 7th.
The performance at the plate was anywhere from outstanding to merely good among the rookie class of 2026. And as many of you reading have probably heard and argued until you ran out of oxygen about, the parts of Stewart’s game outside of the batters box didn’t go as well. His baserunning, despite 15 steals, was a net negative as his caught stealing numbers as well as his general advancements while on the bases when others were batting cost him value. The defense itself wasn’t terrible, but his spending so much time at first base cost him in the value area, too, given that it’s the easiest position on the field to play and just about everyone can play there competently. There’s no doubt that several people have carpel tunnel syndrome arguing over the values around WAR and why Stewart’s total isn’t right.
Today some of the crew at Baseball America (editors note: I write a monthly column about a Cincinnati Reds prospect for Baseball America. I am not involved in any of their rankings in any way and am not consulted for them) ranked the future values for every player who was a rookie in 2026 and lost their “prospect” status (130 career MLB at-bats, 50 innings pitched in a career, or 45 days on an active MLB roster).
They ranked 50 players. Sal Stewart was ranked 20th. When I write up my prospect list for Reds prospects every winter I always encounter questions about why so-and-so was ranked higher than someone else. And even just reading comments on the internet in general you see the same types of reactions: WHY/HOW can you rank this player above/below that player?!
People, in my opinion, get far too caught up with the number that precedes the name on the list and don’t pay nearly enough attention to the write up about the player. We don’t all value players the exact same way. We could have the exact same idea of what kinds of numbers a player would put up and have a different “ranking” despite that.
In the piece by Baseball America the number 20 is next to Sal Stewart’s name. And that alone is going to get some people – probably plenty of you reading this on a website about the Cincinnati Reds – upset. But it’s quite important to understand what they are saying about Stewart before getting upset. There aren’t full write ups for any of the players on the list. Instead they simply list a “grade” and an “upside role”.
For Sal Stewart the grade is a 55. The upside role is listed as All-Star first baseman. What they are saying is he’s expected to be an above-average player who is an All-Star caliber player. That doesn’t sound incorrect, does it? Every player they ranked in the top 25 on this list is considered a potential All-Star caliber player at some point in their career or at worst, a “first division starting caliber player”, or basically a guy worthy of being a quality starter on a high-end playoff team.


