During the offseason someone asked me what the final move I’d like to see for the Cincinnati Reds to put them over the top. My answer was pretty simple: Sign Nick Castellanos – he’s a difference maker in the middle of the lineup. I was sold that it was the move to make.

And then the Reds, who clearly listen to everything I suggest, made the move happen, signing him to 4-year contract – but with option years after both 2020 and 2021.

As a believer that he was a difference maker, even I didn’t expect this kind of start. Nick Castellanos is hitting .340/.411/.840 with an OPS of 1.251. He leads the National League in home runs, RBI, slugging percentage, OPS, total bases, and OPS+ (235).

Nick Castellanos, along with Aaron Judge, are trying to pull “The Babe Ruth” this year. What is a “Babe Ruth”, you ask? Well, that’s where one player hits more home runs than entire teams do for the season. Hat tip to Cespedes Family BBQ on twitter for the note that both players have out homered Arizona.

In a 60-game season, we understand that crazy things could happen because there is less time for things to normalize. One of the bigger things for hitters that we expect to normalize is BABIP. While hitters do have more control over their individual BABIP than pitchers do on their BABIP against them (though they do have a little bit of control here), at the end of the season after 150+ games, a hitter tends to find their true talent level when it comes to BABIP. It doesn’t always happen, but it usually does. Over 60 games (or fewer if a guy doesn’t play every single one of them), that probably isn’t going to happen.

Right now, while hitting .340/.411/.840, you would think that Nick Castellanos had an outrageous BABIP to carry that kind of line. But he really doesn’t. His BABIP in 2020 so far is .345. His BABIP for his career is .334. With that said, his season line probably isn’t sustainable to the point that it has been to this point. The reason for that isn’t the BABIP, which could be sustainable, it’s the home runs. He’s on pace to hit 30 homers this year, which would be 81 in a full season. Castellanos rakes, and he’s got plenty of power – but he doesn’t have that kind of power.

Still, the Reds are getting their money’s worth, and then some early on from their right fielder. He’s been the best hitter in the National League this year. Heck, he’s been the best hitter since last August 1st when he joined the National League with the Cubs after being traded at the deadline in 2019. Since that time, he’s hit .324/.367/.683 with a Major League best 23 home runs (tied with Aaron Judge and Jorge Soler). Only three players have a better OPS+ in that time and all three of them play in the American League (Alex Bregman, Nelson Cruz, and Yordan Alvarez). Only Ketel Marte has been remotely close to as good among National Leaguers, and he’s five points of OPS+ behind Castellanos. The next closest is a pair of Cubs, Anthony Rizzo and Kyle Schwarber, who are 17 points of OPS+ back.

7 Responses

  1. Tom Mitsoff

    To date, he hasn’t shown a weakness on any type of pitch in any particular location. In the first handful of games he was chasing pitches low and away out of the strike zone, but seems to have stopped doing so in recent games. He reminds me of Votto at his peak, when he could seemingly make solid contact on any type of pitch in the strike zone.

  2. Bred

    Interesting article today on the Athletic about Castellanos and Bauer when they faced each other and how they collaborate this year. Castellanos said Bauer challenged him to stop chasing this year. His chase rate is 35.1 this year compared to 40.9 last year. He is hitting .283 against Bauer. Like everyone I hope the FO finds a way to keep them both.

  3. Mark Moore

    He’s been a treat to watch.

    Interestingly enough, when you look only at his batting average, if he goes 1-3 on a given night, it LOWERS it right now. I recall that being the talk back eons ago when George Brett was chasing .400 for a season.

    Let’s see if he can lead the team to victory tonight and line us up for a sweep tomorrow.

  4. ClevelandRedsFan

    Please don’t leave, Nick.

  5. Old-school

    Nick Castellanos, Sonny Gray and Trevor Bauer have carried this team.
    Consummate professionals with passion, enthusiasm and fire. Three reasons why this poor start could change.

  6. Klugo

    Best hitter to don a Reds uni since Votto in his prime.

  7. Old-school

    As for Castellanos defense, the guy said he picked the Reds so he could play RF and not be a DH. He’s not good, but who says he can’t work hard and get better? He’s been a third baseman. Give him some time in RF. He’s better in RF than the Donkey was in LF. I want All stars and Cy Young winners and Silver sluggers and passionate guys on the Reds roster who won’t accept losing.
    Nick Castellanos is that guy. So is Sonny Gray and Bauer outage.