The Cincinnati Enquirer held a fan vote for the All-Time Cincinnati Reds team made up of players throughout the history of the organization. Some choices were a lot easier than others. Here was how the fan vote played out, position by position:
- Johnny Bench – Catcher
- Tony Perez – First Base
- Joe Morgan – Second Base
- Pete Rose – Third Base
- Barry Larkin – Shortstop
- Frank Robinson – Outfield
- Eric Davis – Outfield
- George Foster – Outfield
- Jose Rijo – Starting Pitcher
- Mario Soto – Starting Pitcher
- Jim Maloney – Starting Pitcher
- Don Gullett – Starting Pitcher
- Johnny Cueto – Starting Pitcher
- John Franco – Relief Pitcher
- Aroldis Chapman – Relief Pitcher
- Rob Dibble – Relief Pitcher
That’s not a bad team at all. I’d switch a few of those players for others – but it’s a team that has five Hall of Famers on it – including the gold standard at two different positions (Bench and Morgan at their respective positions).
Let’s have a fun little conversation this Monday afternoon. Who would make your All-Time Reds lineup? Feel free to explain why you would pick one player over the other in the more close calls at a given position.


