The 66-94 Reds host the 81-78 Pirates in this season’s penultimate game at Great American Ball Park today at 4:10 Eastern time.

In this series of season-ending game previews, we took a look at what we’ve learned this year about the position players on Friday. Tomorrow we’ll review what we’ve learned this year about the front office and on-field management. Today, we take a look at the pitching staff. You have been warned.

We learned …

The Cincinnati bullpen was literally just about average, which is saying a lot on this team. The bullpen earned run average of 4.15 was 16th in the 30-team majors, and the Reds split 52 games in which a reliever got the win or the loss.

Three relievers emerged as go-to guys in crunch time:

  • Jared Hughes, 1.99 ERA in 77 innings over 70 appearances
  • David Hernandez, 2.63 ERA in 61.2 innings over 55 games
  • Raisel Iglesias, 29 saves in 33 opportunities, 2.48 ERA in 69 innings

These are the building blocks for next year’s bullpen. Or, they could be valuable trade chips. As has been pointed out by many in Redleg Nation, closers have much more value on contending teams than they do on last-place teams. This would be a way to leverage some assets that would mean more to other teams than they do to Cincinnati.

Lefthander Amir Garrett performed very well in key situations early in the year, but his performance dropped off drastically after he was hit in the leg by a comebacker in June. Interim Manager Jim Riggleman used righty Michael Lorenzen primarily in middle-inning, multi-inning relief. In 44 appearances, Lorenzen pitched 75.1 innings and recorded a 3.35 ERA prior to today’s start.

Garrett and Lorenzen are likely to have the upper hand on bullpen roles going into the spring, presuming they are still with the team. Lefty Wandy Peralta and righty Austin Brice have probably pitched themselves out of the team’s immediate future plans.

Now, regarding the starting pitching …

Luis Castillo finished the season with a 4.30 ERA in a team-leading 169.2 innings. His start to the season was very rough, but after the All-Star break, Castillo recorded a 2.44 ERA over 66.1 innings, striking out 69 and walking only 14. He has been wisely shut down for the year. There is absolutely no reason to risk injury at this point in a lost season.

Castillo has had approximately a season and a half to “figure things out” at the big-league level, and his performance in the past two and a half months seems to indicate that he has. He would go into 2019 as the unquestionable number one starter if no changes to the starting pitching staff are made.

Unfortunately, none of his fellow products of the Reds farm system has come anywhere close to Castillo’s level of advancement. During a meeting between Redleg Nation correspondents, Executive Vice President Dick Williams and Assistant General Manager Sam Grossman, the latter two acknowledged that the fact that young pitchers have not developed over the past couple of years is by far their biggest disappointment. In that August meeting, it was hinted that starting pitchers’ respective performances over the final six weeks of the season was going to be important in determining how much they would be counted on in 2019.

Cody Reed got seven starts after late August, and by and large did decently. In three of those starts which could be considered excellent, he allowed only one earned run in a combined 15.2 innings. In the other three, which would be in the non-acceptable category, he allowed a combined 12 earned runs in 12.2 innings.

After the early part of the season which included some of the team’s most impressive starting pitching performances of the year (3.66 ERA in his first 18 starts), the wheels completely fell off for Tyler Mahle. In four starts following the All-Star Game, Mahle allowed 17 earned runs in 11.1 innings. At this point, he has to be viewed as someone who will have to earn his way back to the big leagues by performing well at Louisville in early 2019.

Sal Romano earned a spot in the rotation out of spring training, but struggled throughout the season. After a 4.45 ERA in 16 games started last year, Romano regressed to a 5.37 ERA in 24 starts in 2018. He’s been used out of the bullpen in recent weeks, and that may be where his future at the major league level lies.

As mentioned yesterday in this space, Anthony DeSclafani has been a major disappointment. Finally returning to the rotation after more than a year of injury rehab, DeSclafani has shown some flashes of his pre-injury form, but they have been very few and far between. A 4.93 ERA over 21 starts has done nothing to inspire confidence and hope in this veteran of four major league seasons.

Homer Bailey no longer has the stuff to consistently get batters out. It’s been a shame for both the team and him personally that injuries, surgeries and rehab over the past three years have left him as statistically the worst starting pitcher in the big leagues (1-14, 6.09 ERA, -1.5 WAR). As we mentioned yesterday regarding Billy Hamilton, you simply can’t use a player with negative WAR in a high number of games and expect your team not to be negatively impacted. Dick Williams said earlier this week that he will have a discussion with Bailey about his future with the team sometime soon. The likely outcome of that meeting is that Bailey will be told if he wishes to remain with the team moving forward, he’ll need to become a reliever.

Matt Harvey finishes the season as essentially the number two starter in the Reds rotation, with a 4.50 ERA over 128 innings. He’ll be a free agent, and I expect the Reds to approach him very quickly with an offer they think is fair based on his performance, age and injury history. If he says no, they will just as quickly move on to their next target – which we’ll talk a lot more about tomorrow in this space.

Robert Stephenson had a terrific year at Louisville: 11-6, 2.87 ERA, 135 strikeouts in 113 innings. Control remained a problem, with 57 walks. He got his chance to get some starts at the big league level, and appeared to have no idea what he was doing (12 walks, nine earned runs in 10.2 innings). You can only give a guy so many chances before you get tired of hearing about the potential and begin to realize it’s never going to materialize. Like all Reds fans, I hope the light goes on for Stephenson and he becomes a fantastic starter. I’m not holding my breath, though.

Starting Pitchers

Jameson Taillon 185 3.16 3.61 22.6% 6%
Michael Lorenzen 75.1 3.35 4.37 16.2% 10%

Taillon has been one of the Pirates’ rotation stalwarts, so with the way the Reds have not been swinging the bats, chances for another low-scoring game from the home team seem pretty likely. Lorenzen is starting his third game this month, and the website is calling today’s start an audition for 2019. Most of this month has been that for the entire pitching staff. A solid performance for Lorenzen over four or five innings will certainly leave a favorable final impression for 2018.


No reliever threw more than 21 pitches in last night’s game, so everyone who is needed in today’s game should be available.

Starting Lineups

Pirates Reds
LF Adam Frazier SS Jose Peraza
CF Starling Marte RF Mason Williams
1B Josh Bell 1B Joey Votto
LF Corey Dickerson 3B Eugenio Suarez
3B Jung Ho Kang LF Scott Schebler
2B Josh Harrison C Tucker Barnhart
SS Jordy Mercer 2B Dilson Herrera
C Jacob Stallings P Michael Lorenzen
P Jameson Taillon CF Billy Hamilton

14 Responses

  1. bouwills

    Mahle, Stephenson, Romano, & Harvey have a higher ERA than Homer Bailey; since the ASB. Troubling, but true.

    • Bill

      I think we can all agree Bailey’s best days are behind him, but for this team to have a chance they really need him to be a serviceable starter. I know he is an easy target with the huge contract and long stints on the DL, but I hope he can figure out something in the off season. Having a better ERA than Harvey is concerning considering everyone wants Homer gone and Harvey signed

  2. Kettering Reds Fan

    Irony abounds.

    We end our season against Pittsburgh with (currently) a 16 game differential in the standings.

    Why is this important to observe?

    Because Pittsburgh is the one team in our division most like us in scale, budget, market size. Chicago has Theo and the Big Checkbook. St. Louis draws over 1 million more in paid attendance at higher prices, plus have a long history of being able to improvise to victory, particularly when it comes to patching together a pitching staff. Milwaukee can draw on the Chicago market to increase scale. Pittsburgh has none of these cards to play. Yet they are 16 games ahead and have developed, at least recently, . “winning momentum” and an ability to locate and develop pitching and to turn over veterans.

    So the year ending question: What do they, as an organization, do differently than ours? Are there lessons to be learned, and, if so, what are they and are they applicable here? Certainly, I -don’t- know, thus the question.

    • Kettering Reds Fan

      A clarification:

      When I discuss the Cardinals, I’m looking at long-term average differential in attendance. It’s far worse if you look at the current season:

      St. Louis 3.4MM+
      Reds struggling to hit 1.6MM

      If you assume average ticket price plus concession rake-offs, etc. at an arbitrary value (say 30-40 dollars per head down to the bottom line), that’s 55-70MM dollars addition to spend on free agents and, more importantly, on organizational development and training methods. For a mid-market club.

      Pittsburgh, on the other hand, is drawing about 100,000 -less- than the Reds and, I suspect, have media funding roughly at parity to us. (Corrections invited, I’m just SWAGing to make an argument).

      Yet, lately, they do more.

      Just sayin’……………

  3. Matt Hendley

    I got a good one…. im waiting for it…..

  4. Phil Gasson

    Billy triples and Grande is on the phone to Bob to support a 5 year deal for Hammy.

  5. Matt Hendley

    Hamilton is the future i am sold,

  6. Jeff Reed

    What’s the point of taking out Lorenzen in the next to last game of another lost season in the 6th. inning with the bases loaded and two outs? The only thing to be gained would have been Lorenzen getting out of the inning not being scored on. I hope there’s a young manager with new ideas come opening day.

    • Aaron Bradley

      Riggelman has stuck to his algorithm that third time thru the lineup is where you get snakebitten,.. the stats back it up.. I don’t necessarily mind this approach going forward by whomever the manager might be.

  7. Matt Hendley

    Reds are going to win….we are going to the playoffz

    • Colorado Red

      When someplace deep under the earth freezes over.

  8. Jeff Reed

    Good pitching before a full house of 42, 600 which will be repeated in six months on opening day also against the Pirates.

  9. Matt Hendley

    Riggleman won us a game 6 year deal for riggleman