That’s the way it’s supposed to work. Dominant pitching from Luis Castillo. Hitting up and down the lineup. Sure, the Brewers were without Ryan Braun (back), Christian Yelich (DL oblique), Eric Thames (groin), their starting catcher (DL calf) and backup catcher (DL shoulder). But even if all those guys were healthy, it wouldn’t have helped tonight. The 8-game losing streak is dead.

Let’s hope the Reds haven’t adopted a strategy of scoring all their April runs in one game. I would have to question that tactic if they did. 

Cincinnati Reds 10 • Milwaukee Brewers 4 || Box Score || Win % || Reds Pitcher Stats || Reds Batters

Luis Castillo picked up where he left off last season. Castillo faced the Brewers in his final start of 2017 before he was shut down. Over 8 dominant innings, he struck out 10 – his major league career high – and walked none. Tonight, Castillo had tremendous control of his fastball, throwing it 95-97 mph. Castillo used his change-up as a strikeout pitch on all but one of his Ks. Castillo pitched 6.2 innings, with 8 strikeouts and 3 walks. This was Castillo’s best start of the season and the second good one in a row for the Reds following Homer Bailey yesterday. 

Castillo helped the Reds from the batter’s box in the 6th inning by smacking a single down the first base line driving in the Reds 5th run. It was Castillo’s third hit in 2018. The 25-year-old had two hits in 2017.

Wandy Peralta pitched a clean 8th. Raisel Iglesias gave up a walk in the 9th. 

The three runs scored by the Reds in the 2nd inning were due to a chain of improbable events. Phillip Ervin, playing for Scott Schebler and Jesse Winker and who looked overmatched all weekend against the Cardinals, doubled to right-center. Tucker Barnhart drove Ervin home on a sharp single. Ervin beat the throw by an eyelash. Phil Gosselin, who was batting .118, singled to center. Castillo advanced both runners with a perfect bunt down the third base line. Then Billy Hamilton, batting .170, lined a two-out single down the right field line driving in two runs. 

The Reds padded their lead in the 6th inning with six runs. It began with back-to-back doubles by Adam Duvall and Scooter Gennett. Later in the inning, Billy Hamilton got his third RBI of the night with a single to center. Jose Peraza, after swinging at a ball that bounced in the opposite batter’s box, doubled down the left field line, plating Castillo and Hamilton. 

Adam Duvall is heating up. He had a double and homer yesterday and was three for five tonight with two doubles. Duvall has raised his OPS from .449 to .686 since Friday.

Scooter Gennett made several nice defensive plays at second base. So did UVA grad (Chad!) Phil Gosselin at third. On the frowning side of the run prevention ledger, Phillip Ervin booted a fly ball that bounced right in front of him. He then threw the ball wildly back to the infield, allowing the batter to advance. In the worst official scoring decision of this century, Ervin was not awarded an error, when he should have had two. 

Joey Votto’s single in the first inning was the number 1,600 hit of his career. Only 500 more and he’ll have almost half what Pete Rose did. Votto missed his first extra-base hit of the season in the the 3rd inning when he shot a ball down the left field line that was foul by an inch or two. Votto then doubled in the the Reds 6-run 6th inning with a shot to centerfield. 

Mark Sheldon filed a report as the game started with the following news: (1) Amir Garrett will remain in the Reds bullpen for the foreseeable future, (2) Jesse Winker, who is nursing a sore shoulder, took batting practice today for the first time in a while, and (3) Scott Schebler was shipped to AA-Pensacola to continue his rehab.

Bryce Harper hit a 406-foot home run as he broke his bat in half. His team, the Washington Nationals are 4-9 since they swept the Reds in the season’s opening series. 

28 Responses

  1. Matthew Habel

    Tomorrow morning is a perfect time for a write up on Duvall has been struggling. Looks like I am a few days late.

    • Chad Dotson

      But that’s a good thing. Glad he’s heating up. (Also, your piece on Duvall is still definitely worth reading!)

  2. nicolecushing

    Listened to the game in its entirety. The Brewers were missing lots of their good players, but then again so were our Redlegs. This is a good time to play them, and I hope the team continues to take advantage of things.

    The run production and timely hitting was good to see.

    Castillo. What can you say that hasn’t already been said? How about this: he’ll be a piece of The Next Good Reds Team. (I know, not exactly a hot take.)

    Gennett: Played really well tonight. Maybe wanting to make an impression on his old team?

    Cody Reed: Reminiscent of Cingrani. HIghly touted prospect who underachieves. Like Cingrani, his best bet might be to get dealt to a one of them thar big city teams with their Inner-nets and geeky lil fellas and fancy-pants analytics that can fix what’s ailin’ him. (Have you seen how well Cingrani’s doing now in L.A.? Did you hear him talk about how the Dodgers’ analytics helped him?)

    Billy Hamilton: Nice to see him contribute the way he did tonight, both in the field and at the plate.

    Duvall: Good to see him do well, too

    Marty & the Cowboy: Tonight I learned that The Cowboy used to have a CB radio back in the day. Now I’m envisioning “Marty & the Cowboy” as an hour long ’70s action series about the two of them makin’ long hauls all over Reds Country while evading crooked cops. There would be plenty of bar fights. During these altercations, their signature move would be for the Cowboy to slam a chair over some biker’s head, after which Marty would kick him in the nuts for the coup de grace.

    • jazzmanbbfan

      Would they be enlisting Joey to help out riding his horse “Nibbles” and wearing his Royal Canadien Mountie uniform?

    • lost11found

      Regarding Reed and Cingrani,

      Sometimes a change of scenery helps. Who knows what advice TC was receiving here. Sometimes the same advise from a different source is better received.

    • Broseph

      I had to dig for that Cingrani piece and see his stats. It’s amazing what can happen when you fix a player’s approach from analytics, rather than fix their mechanics.

      Here’s the Cingrani piece from September:

      If I’m the Reds, I’m reading this and seriously reevaluating my analytics department and how much spend is going there. Huge oversight by them to miss something like this especially since hard throwing lefties are so coveted.

      • SultanofSwaff

        Interesting article that lends more credence to my belief that Reds pitchers overuse the fastball. Reed (and Stephenson and Romano and Finnegan….) all have spotty command. 18 of 22 HR’s allowed were from fastballs.

        There’s no shame in pitching backwards. It’s no more right to ‘command the fastball first’ if you can’t throw your offspeed pitches for strikes than it is to do the opposite, yet all you hear from Price is fastball command……one size fits all.

      • Dewey Roberts

        So it is becoming evident that Price is not only a bad manager, but he is really not a very good pitching coach either.

  3. Chad Dotson

    Why do I only get shout-outs in the recap when Phil Gosselin or Billy Hamilton do well? haha

    That was a great play by Gosselin.

  4. scotly50

    Man, It feels great to have a victory. Reed should have picked up Castillo, but I guess he still is not ready. Votto had some encouraging AB’s. Duvall finally. Scooter had a good game in the field. Nice Win.

  5. Jim Walker

    Now the job is to learn to do this again and again and……..

  6. Reaganspad

    Why wasn’t Tucker bunting in the second when Ervin doubled?

    I am confused

  7. hallaudermilsmithsteen

    Marty in a bar fight and being able to walk away from it; talk about fiction! Real life played out with Thom when it happened up in Chicago.

  8. big5ed

    I am a Cody Reed apologist. Tall lefties take time, and patience will be rewarded.

    But he ought to be in AAA as a starter. And I expect them to do that, as David Hernandez or Shackelford returns from the DL. A few weeks of limited use in Cincinnati won’t hurt Reed, but he needs another 15 starts in AAA.

    • SultanofSwaff

      Me too. Watch Brad Hand in San Diego and tell me the two pitchers aren’t that different. I would argue he needs to throw his slider much more frequently.

  9. bouwills

    Encouraging start by Castillo last night. Something I believe Luis will build on. Cody Reed needs to be demoted to Louisville & used in the Bats rotation. He’s not helping himself or the Reds in his current role with the team. On another note, I don’t think Scooter Gennett got the memo that he was bound to regress offensively this season. No HR yet, but he’s using the whole field & making good contact.

  10. Jeff Reed

    I’m not so sure the Reds are surging but it was a break-through win with good pitching, hitting and defense.

  11. big5ed

    They only have 4 total lefties on the 40-man roster: Finnegan, Reed, Garrett and Peralta. They have 21 RH pitchers, including Desclafani and Rookie Davis, both on the 60-day DL. No lefties on the horizon in AA or AAA, either.

    Poor roster management by the front office.

    • bouwills

      Although Nicolino is not on the 40 man roster (he cleared waivers & was out-righted to Louisville), he’s a serviceable lefty reliever whom the Reds are converting back into a starter. Go figure.

      • big5ed

        Nicolino has been primarily a starter. He has started 33 of his 50 MLB games, and 140 of his 149 minor league games. But from his stats, he appears to be a soft-tossing lefty who would seem to be fitted to relief, even as a LOOGY. He had better K/9 in 2016-17 in AAA against LH hitters than RH, for example.

        They may be giving Nicolino some starts in Louisville, just to see what they have. More likely, though, they’ve ineptly decided to make Garrett a reliever, regardless.

  12. big5ed

    Hamilton by my accounting has an OBP of .386 in his last 11 games. The Reds can live with that.

    They get Schebler and Winker back in the next day or two. Suarez is ahead of schedule. Votto actually looked like Joey Votto yesterday. Duvall and Ervin both got off the interstate last night. And it warms up, at last. Maybe they will be better than the ’62 Mets, after all.

  13. SultanofSwaff

    Excellent points. Peraza’s approach is so one dimensional that it shocks when he pulls a ball with authority.

    I don’t think it was a coincidence that Billy had his best game against a soft tossing pitcher. That’s his hitting speed.

    Eventually one of these two have to get benched, but for a night it was fun to watch.

  14. Alex

    I would trade Duvall, Gennett, Iglesias, Lorenzen, Hamilton, and Mesoraco this summer and get what I can for them. The next winning Reds team will probably not have any of these guys on the roster.

  15. DHud

    Can we talk about how bad Thom is as a color commentator? He couldn’t decide what inning it was or how many runs the Reds scored during their rally tonight, saying “7 run 7th” and “6 run 6th” at two seperate times. He says dumb crap like this every. night.