Hey everyone and welcome to a new column thing I’m going to do most of the time during the season. The premise of said column thing is to take a look at the plethora of new players on the roster/almost on the roster. To see how they’re doing, make predictions, that kind of thing. By way of starting off, today we’re going to take a look at what organizational decisions in spring training might tell us about the status of some of these guys. The column won’t always hit on a bunch of different players, but this seems like a good place to start since the season has only just begun.

Amir Garrett and Rookie Davis – Their stock is obviously way up. They were supposed to be outside shots to make the rotation, but here they are starting the third and fourth games of the season.

Cody Reed and Robert Stephenson – Their stock is substantially down. The Reds seem to be trying to sort roles right now. These two always looked like they might eventually end up in the bullpen and, well, here they are. Ironically, once Arroyo comes up, if Reed is sent down to start in Louisville, it will tell you the Reds see more potential in him than in Stephenson and that the bullpen was just a temporary thing (for now).

Jose Peraza – After several years of being shifted from one team to another and all the positions he played last year, he’s finally being given his shot. We’ll see what he does with it, but he’s certainly looked like he belongs in the majors when he’s been there.

Dilson Herrera – I don’t know where his stock is. The question is with that shoulder. This is the third year in a row it’s caused him problems. Absent the nagging injury, the Reds are probably working harder to find time for him, but for now, he’ll play in Louisville and try to prove he’s healthy.

Jesse Winker – His stock seems pretty unchanged. For now, he needs to hit so well that they can’t keep him down or have Duvall or Schebler hit so poorly that the Reds start looking for alternatives. His time will eventually come. Probably soon. The Reds will eventually need someone besides Votto who can get on base.

Nick Senzel – Eugenio Suarez took reps at short this spring. Hmmm. Why could that be? Oh, right. The Reds have a hot prospect who plays third and they’re looking to trade their shortstop. Honestly, this might tell you more about how they see Herrera than anything else.

9 Responses

  1. sandman

    I wish the Reds would stop going after “prospects” with injury histories.

    • sandman

      Not talking about just Herrera though. Disco to.

      • Andy

        When we traded Latos he had flaws too. That trade was a win for the Reds even if Disco never pitches again, no sense dogging that trade.

      • sandman

        Andy, tell me…how’s that trade a win for the Reds if Disco never pitches again?

  2. Kap

    I can see Suarez moving over to 2nd base with Senzel at 3rd and Peraza at short, assuming Suarez keeps hitting, Senzel reaches the majors, and Herrera ends up being a bust. It’s nice to have that kind of backup plan

    • wkuchad

      Tough call. Suarez has stronger arm, right? Peraza better range. Which is more important for SS?

      • sandman

        wkuchad, I would think both are of equal importance. Yeah, range is great and important but what good is range if you have little to no arm strength to get the ball to first when need be.

  3. Harvey Butler

    The bullpen for the Reds looked good through the first three games of the year going scoreless. Rookie Davis was touched up a bit but got a no decision in the Reds game 3 win over the Phillies. I am optimistic the Reds will have a better season this year.

  4. Michael

    Sandman I would say its a win just based off war and cost. Disco has had 4.1 war since arriving (bbr) and Latos has been negative .4