Okay, time for another community discussion: How valuable is Scott Rolen. The veteran third baseman had a brilliant half-season, followed up by a couple of months (and a miserable post-season) in which Rolen showed his age.

What is the Nation’s collective wisdom regarding Scotty? Is he overrated, underrated, or just rated? What is his future with the Reds, and what should his future be?

Let’s hear it, guys and gals.