| Round | Name | Position | Currently Playing |
| 1 | Mesoraco, Devin | C | Cincinnati |
| 1A | Frazier, Todd | SS | Cincinnati |
| 1A | Lotzkar, Kyle | RHP | Bakersfield |
| 2 | Cozart, Zachary | SS | Cincinnati |
| 3 | Carroll, Scott | RHP | Released 7/12 |
| 3 | Soto, Neftali | SS | Louisville |
| 4 | Stouffer, Blake | 1B | Not signed |
| 5 | Bowman, Andrew | LHP | Released 3/12 |
| 6 | Hildenbrandt, Evan | RHP | Released 3/11 |
| 7 | Waring, Brandon | 3B | To Baltimore - Ramon Hernandez 12/08 |
| 8 | O'Neil, Andrew | RHP | Not signed |
| 9 | Oliveras, Alexis | OF | Released 3/11 |
| 10 | Honeycutt, Harris | RHP | Retired ST 08 |
| 11 | Wideman, Jordan | C | Released (Officially 4/13) |
| 12 | Gaffney, Scott | P | Released 11/11 |
| 13 | Menchaca, Brandon | OF | Released 5/09 |
| 14 | Krebs, Joseph | LHP | Restricted 4/12 (Officially released 4/13) |
| 15 | Klinker, Matthew | RHP | Retired ST 12 (Officially released 4/13) |
| 16 | Snowden, Charles | LHP | Released 11/09 |
| 17 | Craig, Jesse | RHP | Not signed |
| 18 | Taylor, Jordan | RHP | Not signed |
| 19 | Jeffords, Raymond | RHP | Released 5/11 |
| 20 | Kahaulelio, Jacob | SS | Released 11/11 |
| 21 | Horst, Jeremy | LHP | Traded to Phil. 1/12 (Wilson Valdez) |
| 22 | Rhoden, Robert | RHP | Released 11/08 |
| 23 | Bour, Jason | C | Released 3/10 |
| 24 | Meade, Francis | C | Released 11/08 |
| 25 | Rimes, Eli | 1B | Released 11/08 |
| 26 | Partch, Curtis | RHP | Louisville |
| 27 | Roenicke, Jason | RHP | Not signed |
| 28 | Conatser, Jonathan | RHP | Released 4/09 |
| 29 | Otterness, Steven | LHP | Released 2/12 |
| 30 | Bartles, Brett | 3B | Released 11/08 |
| 31 | Hotchkiss, Jordan | RHP | Released 4/12 |
| 32 | Douglas, Brandon | SS | Not signed |
| 33 | Pullen, Brodie | 3B | Released 4/10 |
| 34 | Vinyard, Jeremy | RHP | Released 3/09 |
| 35 | Weber, Thad | RHP | Not signed |
| 36 | Landry, Leon | 3B | Not signed |
| 37 | Alexander, Scott | LHP | Not signed |
| 38 | Ronick, Ari | LHP | Not signed |
| 39 | Nelson, Jimmy | RHP | Not signed |
| 40 | Hopkins, Ross | C | Not signed |
| 41 | Hickey, Kevin | OF | Restricted |
| 42 | Bierman, Sean | LHP | Not signed |
| 43 | Taylor, Austin | 3B | Not signed |
| 44 | Beal, Josh | RHP | Released 4/10 |
| 45 | Brown, Jordan | RHP | Not signed |
| 46 | McGuire, Mike | RHP | Not signed |
| 47 | Benes, Andrew | 3B | Not signed |
| 48 | Henry, Michael | RHP | Released 7/11 |
| 49 | Gray, Cameron | RHP | Not signed |
| 50 | Chambless, Jordan | RHP | Not signed |
| Notes | |||
| DNS =Did Not Sign | |||
| AZL | |||
| Billings | |||
| Dayton | |||
| Bakersfield | |||
| Pensacola | |||
| Louisville | |||
| Cincinnati | |||
| Signed - Not assigned yet | |||